Tomb of Horrors: S1, Its Player Illustrations and the Return Box
Editorial date: ยท TSR Archive
Tomb of Horrors pairs S1's 12-page adventure with a 20-page art book. Compare Return's diary, map booklet and included 1978 facsimile.
Tomb of Horrors is more than its referee text. Both archived S1 printings list a separate 20-page illustration booklet beside a 12-page adventure. The later Return to the Tomb of Horrors box adds another campaign and another set of player-facing aids, while including an earlier adventure facsimile.



The printing descriptions preserve an earlier D&D origin
The 1978 second-printing record credits Gary Gygax and thanks Alan Lucien for the dungeon ideas. It describes the tournament adventure at Origins I as D&D material revised for AD&D. The 1981 fourth-printing description uses different wording for the tournament and the acknowledgment. Read those statements as descriptions attached to particular copies. They are not a full reconstruction of what every tournament participant played.
That source distinction matters when a modern file labels everything simply "the original Tomb." Specify a printing or reproduction when discussing a page, illustration or rule. A work can have an earlier design history and still have a separately identifiable published version. The archive supplies evidence for those identities without establishing that every later printing is textually unchanged.
Player art is a separate reference track
| Record | Adventure material | Player-facing or supporting aids |
|---|---|---|
| S1, TSR 9022; archived 1978 and 1981 copies | 12-page adventure | Separate 20-page illustration book. |
| Return, TSR 1162; 1998, Bruce Cordell | 160-page adventure; 16-page Maps & Monsters book | 32-page Illustration Book, eight-page Journal of the Tomb and a cardstock handout. |
| Facsimile inside the Return box | Inventory lists a 32-page reproduction with unattached cover | Publisher identifies it as a facsimile of the 1978 module. |
S1's brief says the illustrations are keyed to scenes and encounters. Prepare their references alongside the encounter key so a picture appears when it is called for. The Barrier Peaks illustration guide concerns the same broad information boundary, but its booklet and scene numbering belong to S3.
A facsimile inside a box does not make the box a reprint
Return introduces Skull City and a larger story around Acererak's legacy. Its publisher description recommends characters of levels 13-16. That range belongs to this later campaign, not automatically to every edition of Tomb of Horrors. The box's diary and maps also belong to their own adventure structure.
For a used copy, identify the four named booklets or books, the reproduction and the separate handout instead of relying on a photograph of the lid. Then choose whether you are preparing S1 or the Return campaign. Keep the diary and its clues out of a generic folder of S1 images. This comparison supplies an inventory and reading boundary, not trap solutions, an interior collation or certification that any particular sale copy is complete.
Sources and scope
Product fields, inventory and reproduced publisher descriptions: dd1/s1-alt.htm, dd1/s1.htm, tm/tm-tomb.htm. The cover images are preserved local archive files. No trap solutions, complete printing collation or universal recommended level for every Tomb edition. Preparation suggestions are editorial. No new playtest or unseen-copy authentication is claimed.